Allain Roland - When is a push a push?

Anyone else find it ironic that Allain Rowland could see nothing wrong with George North's push on Dulin on Friday yet found that Ivan Dineen definitely pushed Craig Gilroy when Munster played Ulster in January??  

George didnt push him , he just patted him on the back to congratulate him for beating him to the ball   

Yep it's only Wales fans who complain about the ref

Rolland owed Wales one, last time we pushed a frenchman we got a red card.

Conclusively not a push anyway, hand on the shoulder. Dulin clearly went down of his own accord to grab the ball, which he initially did but the collision with his own man dislodged it again.

MunsterMac wrote:Anyone else find it ironic that Allain Rowland could see nothing wrong with George North's push on Dulin on Friday yet found that Ivan Dineen definitely pushed Craig Gilroy when Munster played Ulster in January??  

Nothing ironic one was a push the other wasn't

The ref was right both times.

Nothing worth debating here ...move along

"Conclusively not a push anyway, hand on the shoulder. Dulin clearly went down of his own accord to grab the ball, which he initially did but the collision with his own man dislodged it again."

Exactly. Not a push.

But neither was Dineen's which was practically identical.