606v2 Judges scorecards, Chavez vs Randall 2

Afternoon

The past 12 months have served up what a topical disucussion contentsious decisions are amongst us boxing fans & I thought on the back of the seemingly reasonable top 10 fighters we produced, I thought I'd run a thread each week of controversial fights, and have us scoring the fight. With the average results produced at the end of a week with 606v2 official scorecard, see if we can shed any light on those close fights.

Now below I will serve the links to the fight in question, but since I'm pretty computer illiterate, I'm unable to use the spoiler to show the links directly in 606v2 (I'd be more than happy & grateful if one our clever mods can edit the links for this purpose)

I will produce my scorecard at the below, so just for yourselves now to watch the fight in some spare time (probably can be done before your 1st Coffee break, for you Goverment workers) and produce your scorecard, so results can be calculated at the end of the week, Enjoy !


http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=O5sU7opVw40
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=M6n5K-c8wo8
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_pFP2_Xv6xI
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Vu5WgZdp6JM
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vYuY5d8GxFA


Rodders scorecard
CHAVEZ RANDALL
1 9 10
2 9 10
3 9 10
4 10 9
5 9 10
6 10 9
7 9 10
8 9 9

74 77


How different do you see it,

Thanks and all the best

Rodders

Hopefully get back to this later. Great idea for a thread series. Looking forward to Floyd Castillo 1 if it comes around.

Cheers Jim, good shout, certainly one we'll address mate, if the threads are popular enough. Appreciate not many of us have bundles of time to score a fight but we'll see how it goes.

All the best

Rodders

Great idea, would be interesting to pick some of the controversial decisions and see what we come up with.