Keelan Giles to start against Scotland if George North is injured?

Keelan Giles is starting for the Ospreys today. He's back fit. Do Wales select him to play against Scotland if George North is injured?

If he has a really good game today against Munster there will be pressure on the Welsh management to call him up to the squad.

He's certainly the best Welsh Qualified winger at regional/club level this season, IMO.

In fact, even if George North is fit, maybe Giles still deserves to start against Scotland (especially if he plays well today against Munster).

No, I don't think they will. Steff Evans is actually in the squad so if they were to start anyone new on the wing it would be him, IMO, rather than parachute someone else in over him.

Why not carry on with Cuthbert? Give him a second chance.

OP

You already started a thread: Welsh 23 to play Scotland.

While i realize that one hemisphere is not necessarily working in conjunction with the other one, don't you think a good place to discuss one of those 23 players would be under that thread, or do you feel the necessity to start a new thread for every cognitive revelation you have?